1. Richard Dunne (Everton, Man City, Aston Villa, Queens Park Rangers) - 12 lần.
2. Jamie Carragher (Liverpool) – 7 lần.
=3. Wes Brown (M.U, Sunderland) - 6 lần.
=3. Rio Ferdinand (West Ham, Leeds United, M.U, Queens Park Rangers) - 6 lần.
=3. Phil Jagielka (Everton) - 6 lần.
=3. Derek Mountfield (Everton) - 6 lần.
=7. Martin Skrtel (Liverpool) - 5 lần.
=7. Scott Dann (Birmingham City, Blackburn, Crystal Palace) - 5 lần.
=7. Frank Sinclair (Chelsea, Leicester City) – 5 lần.
=7. Dave Watson (Norwich City, Everton) – 5 lần.